Key Differences Between ByHeart and Bobbie
| Features/Aspect | ByHeart | Bobbie |
|---|---|---|
| Main Ingredient | Organic grass-fed whole milk | Organic, pasture-raised cow milk |
| Protein Source | Alpha-lactalbumin, lactoferrin (mimics breast milk closely) | Organic whey protein concentrate |
| Carbohydrate Source | Lactose | Lactose |
| Fats and Oils | Blend of organic vegetable oils (avoids palm oil), DHA from algal oil | Organic oils (high oleic safflower or sunflower, canola, coconut), DHA from algal oil |
| Prebiotics/Probiotics | Prebiotic GOS | None |
| Unique Selling Point | Clinical trials demonstrate reduced spit-up, soft poops, and efficient weight gain | Prioritizes organic, nutrient-rich ingredients without unnecessary additives |
In this article, we will compare two popular organic baby formulas from the US: Byheart and Bobbie.
We will analyze their ingredients and nutritional compositions to help you make an informed decision for your little one.
Let’s get after it!
Our Short Answer
This is one of the trickier comparisons we’ve tackled. Both formulas are among the best you’ll find in the United States.
They adhere to European standards, are organic, and use high-quality ingredients, while steering clear of palm olein, soy oil, corn syrup, maltodextrin, among others.
Choosing between the two boils down to the following factors:
- Byheart is, on paper, a more complete formula, particularly in terms of protein. It aims to mimic breast milk closely. However, while this sounds promising, after reading numerous reviews, it doesn’t score as highly as Bobbie. Many parents mention their babies don’t digest the formula well.
- Bobbie boasts a shorter ingredient list, aiming to be a nutritionally complete formula that’s easy to digest without overcomplicating things.
From a scientific standpoint, we’d lean towards Byheart being superior.
Discover Byheart Infant Formula: closest to breast milk with a patented protein blend, organic whole milk, and clean-label certified.
- Enhanced digestion and nutrient absorption.
- Clinically proven to support weight gain and reduce spit-up.
- Promotes longer and healthier sleep patterns.
- Boosts brain development and immune health.
- Made in the USA with rigorous safety standards.
Less is more. That is the saying of Bobbie.
Crafted with care, focussed on essential, high-quality ingredients.
Bobbie is your go-to if you want a US-based product with an Organic European Formula quality.
- Organic American Grass-Fed Milk: Sourced from Organic Valley cows
- Iron meets FDA and EU standards
- Perfect Whey:Casein Ratio
- Organic Expeller-Pressed Fat Blend
- Organic Lactose
Overview of the Two Formulas
ByHeart’s formula mimics breast milk with organic grass-fed whole milk and a patented protein blend, emphasizing natural ingredients and easy digestion, proven by clinical trials to reduce spit-up and support growth.
Bobbie uses organic, pasture-raised cow milk, focusing on clean, nutrient-rich ingredients without GMOs or pesticides, meeting U.S. and European standards for infant nutrition.
ByHeart
Byheart is a brand that prides itself on creating a formula that closely mimics breast milk.
With ingredients like organic grass-fed whole milk, alpha-lactalbumin, and lactoferrin, it highlights its effort to provide high-quality nutrition for babies from birth to 12 months.
This formula excludes ingredients like corn syrup, gluten, soy, and palm oil, aiming for an all-natural approach.
Byheart emphasizes easy digestion for babies, supported by a large clinical trial.
This trial demonstrated less spit-up, softer poops, efficient weight gain, and longer stretches between nighttime feeds compared to leading formulas.
Special features include:
- Organic grass-fed whole milk as the primary ingredient.
- A patented protein blend designed to replicate the protein content in breast milk.
- Prebiotic GOS to support good bacteria growth in the gut.
- Free of artificial growth hormones and hexane-extracted DHA.
Bobbie
Bobbie opts for a clean, organic approach right from the start. Its main ingredients are sourced from healthy, pasture-raised cows through Organic Valley®, guaranteeing a nutrient-rich base for infants.
The formula also ensures safety by excluding GMOs and being certified Pesticide-Free.
Bobbie balances traditional and modern nutritional needs by incorporating organic oils (high oleic safflower or sunflower, canola, coconut) and excluding less-desirable additives like corn syrup.
Main features include::
- It aligns with U.S. and European regulatory standards, constantly evolving with new guidelines.
- The formula contains DHA but strictly avoids chemical solvents or inorganic bleaching agents in its preparation.
- Pasture-raised cows provide organic, nonfat milk, ensuring high nutritional value.
- Bobbie has passed rigorous testing for over 400 contaminants, ensuring safety and quality.
Nutritional Composition
Byheart formula mimics breast milk closely with alpha-lac and lactoferrin for balanced growth and digestion. Bobbie opts for organic whey protein, focusing on gentle digestion and muscle development.
Both use lactose as the main carbohydrate, avoiding synthetics.
For fats, Byheart and Bobbie utilize organic vegetable oils and DHA from algal oil for brain health, with Byheart avoiding palm oil and Bobbie emphasizing natural processing.
Protein Content
Byheart: This formula uniquely includes alpha-lac and lactoferrin, two primary proteins found in breast milk, aiming to mimic its protein profile closely. Incorporating whole and hydrolyzed proteins provides a balanced amino acid composition beneficial for your baby’s growth and easy digestion.
Bobbie: Bobbie uses organic whey protein concentrate as a primary protein source. Whey protein is well-known for being gentle on tiny tummies and helps in promoting healthy muscle development. It ensures that babies get the necessary proteins without stressing their digestive system.
The distinction is clear: Byheart aims to replicate breastmilk closely, which, despite its advantages, may cause digestibility issues for some infants, according to reviews. In contrast, Bobbie adopts a simpler approach. The decision boils down to whether to prioritize these reviews or seek the highest quality product.
Carbohydrate Content
Byheart: Byheart formula uses lactose as its sole carbohydrate source, mirroring the carbohydrate composition of breast milk.
Bobbie: Similar to Byheart, Bobbie also prioritizes lactose as its main carbohydrate source, avoiding alternatives like corn syrup or maltodextrin.
There are no differences in carb content, with both formulas using lactose exclusively, which we expect to see in conventional organic formulas.
Fats and Oils
Byheart: Byheart opts for a blend of organic vegetable oils (high oleic sunflower, low erucic rapeseed, coconut, and sunflower) to deliver essential fatty acids important for brain development and overall health. It avoids palm oil and uses DHA algal oil to supply omega-3 fatty acids, crucial for eye and brain development.
Bobbie: The formula incorporates a plant-based blend of organic oils (high oleic safflower or sunflower, canola, coconut) to provide the necessary fats. It carefully selects these oils to avoid using chemical solvents or high heat processing, maintaining a clean profile. DHA from algal oil is also included to support cognitive development.
No big differences in fat content either. Bobbie mentions that the way they process the oils is natural, and Byheart does not promote that (which does not mean they don’t).
Probiotics and Prebiotics
Byheart takes an explicit step to include prebiotics to support gut health, whereas Bobbie maintains a general focus on wholesome, clean ingredients without specific mention of gut health additives.
Both probiotics and prebiotics can play a vital role in a baby’s nutrition, mirroring the benefits found in breast milk. They support a healthy gut environment for digestion, immunity, and well-being.
Byheart incorporates prebiotic GOS (galactooligosaccharides) into its formula. These prebiotics serve as food for good bacteria in the gut, promoting a healthy digestive system.
Bobbie does not explicitly mention the inclusion of prebiotics or probiotics in its list of ingredients. The primary focus is maintaining a clean, organic formula that meets nutritional needs. This is not bad since some babies benefit from a simple formula without special additives.
Best Places to Buy ByHeart and Bobbie
ByHeart
Bobbie
Less is more. That is the saying of Bobbie.
Crafted with care, focussed on essential, high-quality ingredients.
Bobbie is your go-to if you want a US-based product with an Organic European Formula quality.
- Organic American Grass-Fed Milk: Sourced from Organic Valley cows
- Iron meets FDA and EU standards
- Perfect Whey:Casein Ratio
- Organic Expeller-Pressed Fat Blend
- Organic Lactose
Organic nutrition for sensitive babies.
- Partially Hydrolyzed Proteins: Breaks down proteins into smaller peptides, supporting easier digestion and comfort for gassy or sensitive tummies.
- No Soy
- No Corn Syrup
- No Maltodextrin
- No Palm Oil
What are some alternatives to ByHeart and Bobbie?
Even though Bobbie and Byheart are the best organic formulas in the US, other European alternatives surpass them regarding organic-certifications and ingredient composition.
Here are our favorites:
- Kendamil: Known for using whole milk, Kendamil is a unique choice. It incorporates Human Milk Oligosaccharides (HMOs) and Milk Fat Globule Membrane (MFGM), aiming to closely mimic the composition of breast milk for better digestion and nutrient absorption. *Read: Kendamil vs Byheart | Kendamil vs Bobbie
Kendamil Organic offers a wholesome start to life.
- Human Milk Oligosaccharides (HMOs) and MFGM (Milk Fat Globule Membrane)
- EU-Certified Organic Milk
- Whole Cream Milk = Less Vegetable Oils
- Vegetarian-Friendly
- Nutrient-Rich
- Allergen-Free
- Ethically Sourced
- Holle: This brand boasts a Demeter Certification for its biodynamic agriculture approach to sourcing ingredients, ensuring the purest form of organic farming practices is adhered to. Holle’s simple, clean ingredients with no unnecessary additives make it a highly trusted option for parents seeking organic baby nutrition rooted in nature’s best. *Read: Holle vs Bobbie | Holle vs Byheart
Holle stands out for its organic and natural ingredients.
- Demeter Certified: The highest organic standard in Europe, ensuring biodynamic, chemical-free farming.
- Nutrient-rich: Packed with essential vitamins (A, D, E), minerals, and fatty acids (DHA & ARA).
- Pure & Simple: Free from artificial sweeteners, GMOs, chemicals, hormones, gluten, and soy.
- Organic Lactose & Milk Fats: Mimics natural breast milk carbohydrates.
- Hipp: Hipp specializes in formulas tailored to specific digestive needs, offering solutions for babies with sensitivities like colic or reflux. It incorporates prebiotics and probiotics into its formulas to support optimal gut health from an early age. Hipp’s dedication to organic, beneficial ingredients helps cater to various dietary requirements while promoting healthy growth and development. *Read: Hipp vs Byheart | Hipp vs Bobbie
Hipp formula is the best to provide your baby with a wholesome and easily digestible formula.
- Breastmilk-Like Composition: Natural probiotic lactic acid cultures from real breast milk and lactose as the main carbohydrate.
- EU Organic Certified: Sourced from biodynamic farms.
- Nutrient-Enriched: Contains prebiotics (GOS) and essential fatty acids (DHA & ARA)
- Allergen-Free: Free from artificial sweeteners, GMOs, gluten, soy, peanuts, and eggs.
Last Words
We hope this comparison between Byheart and Bobbie has helped you make an informed decision for your baby.
If you have further questions, leave a comment or contact us at [email protected]
Happy feeding!
We’re Maria and Alberto, a married couple and educators who are nutrition enthusiasts. Even before we had kids, we were already crazy about nutrition.
We’d read scientific articles, watch videos from nutritionists, and spend hours listening to nutrition podcasts.
Today, we continue doing this, but in a different way, as we’ve learned to sift through the noise and trends. Nutrition, like any other field of knowledge, the more you read and learn, the more you develop a comprehensive understanding of reality, and that’s what has happened to us.
Before having our first child, we focused on learning everything we could about child nutrition, using the same techniques we had already employed, backed by our extensive knowledge in nutrition.
Our mission is to help other parents with their children’s nutrition, to help them become the best versions of themselves.
If we are what we eat and drink, which is absolutely true, let’s do it right!
