NannyCare vs Hipp: Which Goat Milk Formula Is Superior?

Key Differences Between NannyCare and Hipp

Criteria	NannyCare	Hipp
Brand Origin	New Zealand	Germany
Years of Experience	Over 30 years	Over 100 years
Reputation	Known for organic ingredients and sensitive tummies	Known for eco-friendly practices and quality
Main Focus	Producing softer curds for sensitive tummies	Providing essential nutrients and prebiotics
Protein Source	Goat milk protein	Goat milk protein
Whey Addition	No whey added	Whey added to mimic breast milk protein composition
Primary Carbohydrate	Lactose	Lactose with added prebiotic fibers
Palm Oil	Palm oil-free	Includes palm oil
Fats and Oils	High oleic sunflower oil, rapeseed oil, and sunflower oil	Palm oil, rapeseed oil, and sunflower oil
Omega-3 and Omega-6	Yes, from fish oil and Mortierella alpina oil	Yes, from fish oil and Mortierella alpina oil
Prebiotics and Probiotics	No added prebiotics or probiotics	Includes galacto-oligosaccharides, a prebiotic derived from lactose
✨ Special Strengths	Purity, fewer additives, no palm oil	Added prebiotics and whey protein for better digestion
Cost and Availability	Comparable pricing, widely available online	Comparable pricing, widely available online
Best Suited For	Infants with sensitive tummies, no palm oil	Infants needing better digestion support, prebiotics and whey protein

Blwstore is supported by its audience. When you buy through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission.

Are you a parent searching for the best goat milk formula for your little one? You’re not alone!

Goat milk formulas are gaining popularity, particularly among parents of infants with sensitive digestive systems.

This article will dive deep into two of the best goat milk formulas, NannyCare and Hipp, two leading brands in this field.

We’ll be comparing the Stage 1 formulas of both brands, but keep in mind that our comparison can also be applied to the follow-on formulas, as the ingredients do not vary significantly across stages.

By the end of this article, you’ll be well-equipped to decide which formula is best for your baby.

Let’s get after it!

Our Short Answer

Choosing between NannyCare and Hipp Goat is not easy, as both formulas offer high-quality ingredients and adhere to strict nutritional standards.

If you prefer a formula with fewer additives and no palm oil, NannyCare is the perfect choice.

If you’re looking for a formula enriched with prebiotics and whey protein for better digestion, Hipp Goat is your go-to.

Rest assured, either choice ensures a nutrient-rich, delicious formula your baby will love.

In our specific case with our son, we would have probably gone for NannyCare, because he did not need prebiotics and had no digestive issues.

Best Store to Buy Hipp and Nannycare Formulas

At BLWStore, we may earn a commission from some of the products featured on our website through affiliate partnerships with retailers. We want to be transparent with our readers and let you know that we do not receive any products for special consideration. The commission we earn helps support our website and allows us to continue providing helpful information and product recommendations. Thank you for your support!

Brand Reputation

NannyCare and Hipp are trusted brands of goat milk baby formula.

NannyCare is known for organic ingredients and softer curds for sensitive digestive systems, while Hipp is renowned for eco-friendly and organic practices and their HiPP Dutch Goat Stage 1 formula.

NannyCare Reputation

NannyCare, a New Zealand-based company, is a pioneer in the field of goat milk formulas.

With over 30 years of experience, NannyCare has cemented its reputation as a trusted manufacturer of high-quality baby formula.

Their commitment to organic ingredients, biodynamic farming, and animal welfare is reflected in their products, contributing to their status as the number one baby formula across England.

Their flagship product, NannyCare Goat Milk Formula Stage 1, is specially formulated to meet the individual needs of infants with sensitive digestive systems.

It’s pure, gentle, and packed with all the necessary nutrients for your baby’s growth and development.

What sets NannyCare apart from other brands is their focus on producing goat milk that forms softer curds, which is gentler on a baby’s tummy.

Hipp Reputation

Now, let’s move on to Hipp. Originating from Germany, Hipp is a century-old company renowned for its eco-friendly and organic business practices.

Hipp’s meticulous attention to detail, stringent quality checks, and commitment to environmental sustainability make it a highly respected brand in the baby food industry.

Their entry into the goat milk formula market, HiPP Dutch Goat Stage 1, is a testament to their commitment to innovation and quality.

Infused with essential nutrients and naturally occurring prebiotics, HiPP Dutch Goat offers a wholesome and balanced diet for your baby.

Their formula is free from synthetic ingredients, artificial sweeteners, and common allergens, making it a safe choice for your little one.

Nutritional Composition

As parents, we’re not just feeding our babies, we’re also nourishing them.

Every ingredient matters, and it’s crucial to understand the nutritional composition of their formula. Let’s take a look at how they compare in terms of nutritional composition and ingredients.

NannyCare and Hipp use goat milk protein which is easier to digest than cow’s milk protein.

NannyCare doesn’t include whey, unlike Hipp. Both formulas use lactose, but Hipp also adds prebiotic fibers.

NannyCare is palm oil-free, while Hipp includes it.

Protein Content

The protein in both NannyCare and Hipp originates from goat milk.

Why is this so important?

Goat milk protein is easier to digest and less likely to cause allergies than cow’s milk protein. It forms a softer curd in the stomach, making it gentler on your baby’s tiny tummy.

NannyCare’s protein content per 100ml prepared feed is 1.3g, the same as Hipp. The difference lies in their approach:

NannyCare’s formula doesn’t include whey, unlike Hipp’s formula which adds it to mimic the protein composition of breast milk.

NannyCare’s goal is to minimize the chemical processes involved in manufacturing their formula to maintain its purity.

Although whey protein is easier to digest than casein, NannyCare doesn’t add it, as goat milk is already easier to digest compared to cow’s milk. This is their unique approach.

Carbohydrate Content

Carbohydrates are essential for energy, and the primary carbohydrate in both formulas is lactose, derived from goat milk.

Lactose is also the main carbohydrate in breast milk, making it a natural choice for baby formula.

NannyCare contains 7.4g of sugars per 100ml, all of which comes from lactose.

Similarly, Hipp contains 7.0g of sugars per 100ml, with 6.9g from lactose and the rest from galacto-oligosaccharides. These galacto-oligosaccharides are prebiotic fibers that support healthy gut bacteria, offering an extra benefit.

Fats and Oils

Babies need fats for brain development and growth.

Both NannyCare and Hipp use a blend of vegetable oils to provide essential fatty acids. NannyCare’s fat content per 100ml prepared feed is 3.4g, while Hipp’s is slightly higher at 3.6g.

NannyCare uses a blend of high oleic sunflower oil, rapeseed oil, and sunflower oil.

Importantly, NannyCare’s formula is palm oil-free, which can be a deciding factor for some parents.

Hipp, on the other hand, includes palm oil in its blend along with rapeseed oil and sunflower oil.

Both formulas also incorporate fish oil and Mortierella alpina oil for Omega-3 (DHA) and Omega-6 (ARA), vital for brain and eye development.

Pros and Cons of Organic Palm Oil In Baby Formula

	Pros	Cons
1.	Nutritionally Rich: Palm oil is high in palmitic acid, which is closer to the fat profile in breast milk.	Digestibility Issues: Some studies suggest that palm oil might interfere with calcium absorption and harden stool, causing constipation in some babies.
2.	Sustainable Source: Organic palm oil comes from certified sustainable sources, ensuring it’s environmentally friendly.	Environmental Concerns: Even though it’s organic, some concerns remain about the overall impact of palm oil cultivation on deforestation and habitat destruction.
3.	Adds Creaminess: Palm oil helps to achieve a creamy texture in the formula, making it more palatable for babies.	Potential Allergen: While rare, some babies might have an allergic reaction to palm oil.

Nutritional Facts Comparison Table

Nutrient	NANNYCARE	?HIPP GOAT
Energy	66 kcal	66 kcal
Total Fat	3.4 g	3.6 g
Saturates	1.2 g	1.5 g
Monounsaturates	1.6 g	1.6 g
Polyunsaturates	0.53 g	0.5 g
Omega 6 (linoleic acid)	400 mg	0.4 g
Omega 3 (α-linolenic acid)	53 mg	0.06 g
DHA	15 mg	13.2 mg
ARA	16 mg	13.2 mg
Carbohydrate	7.4 g	7.0 g
Sugars	7.4 g	7.0 g
Protein	1.3 g	1.3 g
Sodium	19 mg	20 mg
Potassium	70 mg	70 mg
Chloride	57 mg	58 mg
Calcium	53 mg	67 mg
Phosphorus	39 mg	38 mg
Iron	0.65 mg	0.5 mg
Zinc	0.49 mg	0.5 mg
Copper	0.049 mg	53 mcg
Manganese	0.009 mg	5 mcg
Fluoride	0.0065 mg	< 1 mcg
Selenium	2.5 mcg	3.0 mcg
Iodine	13 mcg	13 mcg
Vitamin A	56 µg	54 µg
☀️Vitamin D₃	1.4 µg	1.5 µg
Vitamin E	1.5 mg	0.66 mg
Vitamin K₁	6.7 µg	5.1 mg
Vitamin C	13 mg	8.9 mg
Vitamin B₆	0.036 mg	0.029 mg
Folic acid	22 µg DFE	10 mcg
Vitamin B₁₂	0.18 µg	0.10 mcg

Probiotics and Prebiotics

Prebiotics and probiotics improve gut health and immunity, but some formulas don’t include them.

NannyCare is simple and doesn’t have added prebiotics or probiotics.

Hipp has galacto-oligosaccharides, a prebiotic that aids digestion and immunity.

Prebiotics and probiotics are key to developing a healthy gut microbiota, enhancing digestion and supporting the immune system, however, some formula brands do not include them since they are not essential and are considered additives by some experts.

NannyCare formula does not contain added prebiotics or probiotics, focusing on simplicity and minimal processing.

Hipp, however, takes a different approach. Hipp Stage 1 includes galacto-oligosaccharides, a type of prebiotic derived from lactose.

These prebiotics can help cultivate a healthy environment for beneficial gut bacteria to flourish, aiding digestion and supporting immunity.

Cost and availability

NannyCare and Hipp Goat Milk formulas are similarly priced, reflecting their premium ingredients and careful manufacturing process.

For parents in the United States and across the globe, these formulas are conveniently accessible through various online retailers (see the best ones below).

This wide availability makes it easy for parents to choose the best formula for their little ones without worrying about local supply constraints.

Best Places to Buy NannyCare and Hipp

What are the best alternatives to NannyCare and Hipp Goat?

While NannyCare and Hipp Goat are excellent choices, other brands provide high-quality goat milk formulas as well.

Holle Goat is one such alternative, renowned for its Demeter certification, indicating a high standard of biodynamic farming practices. *Read: Holle vs NannyCare

Kendamil is another worthy contender. Its unique vegetarian formula has won widespread acclaim and even the support of the British royal family. Kendamil’s commitment to creating nutritionally complete, ethically sourced formulas sets it apart. *Read: Kendamil vs NannyCare

Lastly, Kabrita specializes exclusively in goat milk formulas, maintaining a single-minded focus on delivering the best possible product. Their formulas are well-received worldwide, making Kabrita a reliable alternative if you’re exploring different goat milk options. *Read: Kabrita vs NannyCare

Conclusion

In conclusion, both brands offer truly high-quality goat milk formulas, each with their unique strengths.

NannyCare stands out for its purity, using fewer additives and consciously avoiding palm oil. If you’re looking for the simplest goat milk formula on the market, NannyCare is your answer.

On the other hand, Hipp Goat has added prebiotics and whey protein that aid digestion, providing a comprehensive nutritional profile. If these added benefits align with your baby’s needs, Hipp Goat is your formula of choice.