Bobbie vs Lebenswert: Which Formula Is Better For Your Baby?

Key Differences Between Bobbie and Lebenswert

Feature/Aspect	Bobbie	Lebenswert
Organic Certification	USDA Organic, exceeds US standards	Bioland, meets EU organic standards
Protein Source	Organic nonfat milk, organic whey protein concentrate	Organic skimmed milk, demineralized whey powder
Fat Profile	Blend of organic high oleic oils, canola oil, coconut oil	Blend of organic vegetable oils: palm, sunflower, rapeseed
Carbohydrate Source	Organic lactose	Organic lactose
Special Nutrients	DHA from algae for brain development	DHA from algae for brain development
Availability	US only	US (though European formula retailers) and international
Prebiotics/Probiotics	None	None

Are you a parent searching for the ideal baby formula for your little one?

This article will compare two popular organic baby formula brands: Bobbie and Lebenswert.

We will delve into their ingredients, nutritional compositions, and other factors to help you decide on your baby’s health and well-being.

Let’s begin!

Our Short Answer

After analyzing both formulas in depth, the truth is that this is one of the closest comparisons we have ever written.

Both formulas follow the same principle: organic ingredients and simplicity.

We can’t decide on an absolute winner, so it will largely depend on where you live.

If you are from the US, Bobbie’s is your best option, because of availability.

If you are from the US or another part of the world, then Lebenswert is a better choice, as Bobbie is only available in the US at the moment.

If we had to choose a winner, Lebenswert is slightly better for two reasons:

• Its organic certification is stricter and more difficult to obtain (usually the case with US certifications).
• It’s slightly easier to digest on paper for its demineralized whey protein.
• Its fat blend is slightly better (read why below).

Overview of the Two Formulas

Bobbie formula emphasizes organic ingredients and non-GMO, grass-fed cow milk, focusing on safety and quality without chemical solvents or inorganic agents. It’s pesticide-free, exceeds US standards, and incorporates European-inspired nutrients like DHA, avoiding corn syrup.

Lebenswert offers a simple, organic formula with ingredients from biodynamic farms, certified by Bioland. It prioritizes lactose for energy, is starch- and maltodextrin-free, and includes DHA and LCPs for brain development, avoiding GMOs and artificial additives.

Bobbie

Bobbie formula takes pride in its clean and organic approach.

Starting with quality, non-GMO ingredients, Bobbie uses organic lactose and nonfat milk from grass-fed cows as its primary components.

These healthy cows are raised on pastures and have a diet of at least 85% grass.

Their commitment to safety and quality doesn’t stop there; Bobbie eliminates chemical solvents or inorganic bleaching agents in its oil blends, including organic high oleic (sunflower or safflower) oil, canola oil, and coconut oil.

What sets Bobbie apart is its dedication to being pesticide-free—a claim backed by the Clean Label Project.

Their formulas meet and exceed US regulations, reflecting their global quality and safety standards.

They also incorporate important nutrients inspired by European standards, such as DHA, while avoiding less desirable ingredients like corn syrup.

Lebenswert

Lebenswert formula is celebrated for its simplicity and organic purity.

It is certified by Bioland, a top sustainability certification body, and meets the EU’s rigorous standards for organic farming.

The primary ingredients include skimmed milk from cows raised on biodynamic (sustainable) farms and whey powder, creating a formula that mirrors breastmilk’s natural composition.

From the get-go, Lebenswert emphasizes minimalism in its ingredient list while ensuring each component adds to the nutritional value necessary for babies up to 6 months old.

This formula is starch- and maltodextrin-free, focusing instead on lactose to provide energy in a form that’s gentle on tiny digestive systems.

Adding DHA and LCPs supports brain development without compromising sensitivity issues.

Lebenswert’s dedication to creating a wholesome product extends to avoiding GMOs, artificial sweeteners, flavors, preservatives, gluten, and soy.

Nutritional Composition

Bobbie formula offers organic milk-based proteins and lactose, mirroring breast milk, with fats from organic oils including DHA-rich algae.

Lebenswert similarly provides organic proteins and lactose, with a slightly preferred fat profile including sustainably sourced palm oil and DHA-rich algae, emphasizing natural nutrition.

Protein Content

Bobbie: The protein in Bobbie formula comes primarily from organic nonfat milk and organic whey protein concentrate. Given the organic sourcing, the proteins are from cows that graze on pesticide-free pastures, ensuring a clean and natural product.

Lebenswert: In Lebenswert formula, protein is delivered through skimmed milk and demineralized whey powder. Like Bobbie, this approach seeks to closely replicate the nutritional profile of breast milk to support your baby’s developmental needs.

Both formulas use organic skimmed milk and have a 60:40 whey-to-casein ratio. The main difference is that Lebenswert uses demineralized whey, which is easier to digest for some babies than whey protein concentrate. Apart from that, no differences at all.

Carbohydrate Content

Bobbie: The main carbohydrate in Bobbie’s formula is organic lactose, the primary carbohydrate in breast milk. By sticking with lactose, Bobbie ensures that babies receive energy in its most natural form without relying on added sugars or starches.

Lebenswert: Lebenswert also uses organic lactose as its primary carbohydrate source. This choice reflects a commitment to simplicity and quality and underscores the brand’s focus on providing energy in a way that’s closest to what nature intended.

Lactose is a significant energy source and supports calcium absorption—a vital mineral for bone development. There are no differences in carb content.

Fats and Oils

Bobbie: Fats in Bobbie formula are sourced from a blend of organic high oleic (sunflower or safflower) oil, canola oil, and coconut oil, and oils rich in DHA, like Schizochytrium sp. oil for brain development.

Lebenswert: The fat content in Lebenswert comes from organic vegetable oils, including palm oil (from sustainable farming), sunflower oil, and rapeseed oil. It also includes oil from microalgae Schizochytrium sp., which is rich in DHA. This combination offers a spectrum of necessary fatty acids while supporting sustainable agricultural practices.

In terms of fats, one would think that Bobbie is better for not having palm oil but the truth is that if the palm oil is organically grown, it’s a whole different story.

Palm oil has a bad rep because it is bad for the environment and because its refined version (palm olein) has been shown to reduce calcium absorption. However, when it’s organically grown, it’s among the best vegetable oils because of palmitic acid, a fatty acid similar to breast milk fats.

Having said this, Bobbie has coconut oil, the most nutritious vegetable oil there is, but it has a high oleic sunflower, which is worse than the non-high oleic version.

In our opinion, Lebenswert fat profile is slightly better, but not enough to make your decision based on that.

Probiotics and Prebiotics

Bobbie and Lebenswert formulas do not contain prebiotics or probiotics, but focus on using lactose and organic ingredients. 

Neither Bobbie nor Lebenswert baby formulas contain probiotics or prebiotics.

Both use lactose as a primary carbohydrate source that promotes beneficial gut bacteria growth, avoid additives, and focus on using the highest-quality organic ingredients.

Other formula options may be more suitable for parents who prioritize prebiotics and probiotics in their baby’s diet.

Best Online Stores to Buy Bobbie and Lebenswert

We recommend Organic’s Best or TheMilkyBox for Lebenswert and other European Organic Formulas, as well as Bobbie’s website to buy Bobbie formula.

What are The Best alternatives to Bobbie and Lebenswert?

We always recommend parents keep learning about other brands before deciding.

These are the ones we recommend as great alternatives to Bobbie and Lebenswert:

Holle: A European brand offering organic, Demeter-certified baby formulas with high-quality ingredients and a strong focus on sustainability. Read: Holle vs Bobbie and Holle vs Lebenswert

HiPP is another European brand that offers a wide range of organic baby formulas, including options for special digestive needs like constipation, reflux or allergies. *Read Hipp vs Bobbie and Hipp vs Lebenswert

Kendamil: A UK-based brand that offers organic baby formulas made with whole milk and without palm oil. *Read Kendamil vs Bobbie and Kendamil vs Lebenswert

Last Words

We hope this comparison between Bobbie and Lebenswert formulas has helped you make an informed decision.

If you have any questions, please comment below or contact us at [email protected]. We’ll be happy to help.

Happy feeding!