Hipp vs Jovie: Which Goat Milk Formula Is Better?

Key Differences Between Hipp and Jovie

	Hipp	Jovie
Brand Reputation	Quality, broad-range organic formulas	Simplicity-focused, organic & holistic
Nutritional Composition	Goat milk nutrients, maltodextrin, blend oils	Whole goat milk nutrients, lactose, oils
Probiotics and Prebiotics	Adds prebiotic fiber	Prebiotics: GOS
Cost and Availability	More affordable, widely available	Pricier, widely available
Ideal For	Budget-conscious, need added prebiotics, night-feeders	Prefer purity, no extra additives, premium quality

Blwstore is supported by its audience. When you buy through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission.

As a parent, the nutrition of your little one is probably one of your top priorities.

Choosing the right baby formula can feel like navigating a labyrinth, and that’s why we’re here.

So, let’s dive into the world of organic goat milk formulas and answer the question on your mind: Hipp vs Jovie – which one is better for your baby?

Our Short Answer

Another difficult comparison, but in this Hipp vs Jovie one, we’ve got some critical differences, so bear with us.

Choose Hipp if:

• You’d like prebiotics in your formula

• Your baby gets hungry a lot or wakes up at night wanting more milk

• You’d like a formula that’s a bit more affordable

Choose Jovie if:

• You don’t want extra additives in your baby’s formula and want a simple and pure goat milk formula

• You don’t mind paying extra for a premium and pure product

At BLWStore, we may earn a commission from some of the products featured on our website through affiliate partnerships with retailers. We want to be transparent with our readers and let you know that we do not receive any products for special consideration. The commission we earn helps support our website and allows us to continue providing helpful information and product recommendations. Thank you for your support!

Brand Reputation

The reputation of a brand plays a crucial role in our decision-making process.

We want assurance that our baby gets the best possible nutrition, and the brand’s reputation often gives us that confidence.

Let’s explore Hipp and Jovie’s reputations to clarify your quest for the perfect goat milk formula.

Hipp Reputation

HiPP is a name that resonates with trust and quality in the world of organic baby formulas.

Having cultivated a strong reputation over the years, HiPP is known for its commitment to delivering only the highest quality organic baby formulas.

Their organic practices extend beyond mere regulatory standards, ensuring your baby gets the non-toxic nourishment they deserve.

While HiPP has its roots in Germany, they’ve made a name for themselves globally with their wide range of specialty formulas.

They cater to a variety of nutritional needs with specialty formulas like HiPP anti-reflux and HiPP Comfort.

But the crown jewel in their extensive lineup is the HiPP Dutch Goat Milk Formula. This formula takes the wholesome goodness of goat’s milk and blends it with HiPP’s organic commitment, resulting in a product that’s truly top-tier.

Jovie Reputation

On the other hand, Jovie, although a newer entrant, has carved a niche for itself with its premium organic goat milk formula.

One of the brand’s core strengths is its commitment to keeping things simple and wholesome. Jovie’s formula is derived from organic whole goat’s milk without any unnecessary additives.

Jovie has proven that goat’s milk is not just a great alternative for babies with cow’s milk sensitivities, but also a fantastic choice for all infants.

By prioritizing organic and holistic farming practices, Jovie ensures that their goat milk formula is devoid of harmful pesticides, herbicides, and GMOs.

The brand’s dedication to animal welfare and sustainability further adds to its reputation as a responsible and trustworthy provider of organic baby formulas.

Nutritional Composition

Let’s peel back the layers of Hipp and Jovie’s goat milk formulas and see how their nutritional compositions compare.

HiPP and Jovie goat milk formulas have similar protein, carbohydrate, and fat content. Both have pros and cons, and their sources differ slightly.

Protein Content

Protein is a key player in your baby’s growth and development. But the quantity is just one part of the equation – the source matters too.

HiPP Dutch Goat Milk Formula uses organic goat’s milk as the primary protein source. It’s a complete protein source, meaning it contains all the essential amino acids your baby needs. The protein content in HiPP is finely balanced to mimic breast milk as closely as possible.

On the flip side, Jovie also uses organic whole goat’s milk as its primary protein source. Jovie’s protein content is designed to align with the naturally occurring levels in goat’s milk, resulting in a wholesome and well-balanced formula.

Both formulas have the same protein content and sources.

Carbohydrate Content

Carbohydrates are the main source of energy for your baby’s rapidly developing body and brain. Hence, it’s vital to ensure they’re getting it from the right sources.

HiPP Dutch Goat Milk Formula uses lactose, the natural sugar in milk, as the primary carbohydrate source. This is complemented with organic maltodextrin, derived from corn, to ensure a sustained energy release.

Jovie, sticking to its commitment to simplicity, relies solely on lactose from organic goat’s milk as the carbohydrate source. This approach stays true to the natural composition of goat’s milk, ensuring your baby receives easily digestible and wholesome nourishment.

Pros and Cons of using Organic Maltodextrin in Baby Formula

Pros	Cons
Easily Digestible	❌ Allergic Reactions
Maltodextrin is a complex carbohydrate that is easily broken down and absorbed in the small intestine. It releases energy at a slower rate so babies feel fuller.	Some babies might have mild allergic reactions to maltodextrin, like to any other ingredient.
Low Sweetness	Potential for Overfeeding
Maltodextrin is not as sweet as other sugars like corn syrup solids, which can help prevent a preference for overly sweet tastes from developing early in life.	Because it’s less filling than other carbohydrates at the beginning, babies might drink more. However, this rarely happens.
Thickening Property	Gut Health Impact
It’s used as a thickener in baby formulas, making the mixing process easier and also more filling.	Some studies have suggested that maltodextrin can potentially disrupt the gut flora balance. However, this is fought by adding pre and probiotics.
Energy Booster	Blood Sugar Levels
Maltodextrin provides a quick source of energy, which can be beneficial for growing babies and make them more physically active.	It is said that maltodextrin can sometimes spike blood sugar levels, but this only happens by overconsuming.
Organic Standards	Less Nutritious
If the maltodextrin is organic, it has been produced without the use of pesticides or other harmful chemicals.	Compared to other complex carbohydrates, maltodextrin is less nutritious.
Non-GMO	Potential Digestive Issues
Organic maltodextrin is non-GMO, meaning it doesn’t contain any genetically modified organisms.	In very few cases, maltodextrin might cause mild digestive issues.

Fats and Oils

Fats are essential to your baby’s overall growth, brain development, and energy needs. But not all fats are created equal, and the source of these fats makes a world of difference.

HiPP Dutch Goat Milk Formula uses a blend of essential oils, including palm oil, rapeseed oil, and sunflower oil, to mimic the fatty acid composition of breast milk. These oils are converted into a unique fat blend that provides essential long-chain polyunsaturated fatty acids, critical for your baby’s brain and eye development.

Jovie, however, takes a slightly different approach. Their formula includes essential fats derived directly from organic whole goat’s milk, supplemented with organic sunflower and rapeseed oil. This blend ensures that your baby is getting a well-rounded dose of healthy fats, aiding their growth and development.

Pros and Cons of using Organic Palm Oil in Baby Formula

Pros	Cons
Palmitic Acid	❌ Inefficient Absorption
Palm oil contains high levels of palmitic acid, a fatty acid that is also found in breast milk. This can help mimic the nutritional content of breast milk in formulas.	Palm oil-derived palmitic acid may not be as efficiently absorbed as the palmitic acid from breast milk. When bound to calcium in the intestines, it can form “soaps” leading to harder stools and potentially less calcium available for the baby.
Energy Source	Environmental Impact
Fats are an essential source of energy for growing babies, and palm oil can help provide this.	Palm oil production is often linked to deforestation and habitat. Thankfully, Hipp’s palm oil is organically grown.
Vitamin A Source	❌ Potential Allergic Reactions
Palm oil is a source of beta-carotene, which the body can convert into vitamin A, a necessary nutrient for developing babies.	Though rare, some babies might have allergic reactions to palm oil.
Organic Standards	Saturated Fats
If the palm oil is organic, it is produced without the use of pesticides or other harmful chemicals.	Palm oil is high in saturated fats. This should not be a problem if you follow the feeding guidelines provided by your pediatrician.
Non-GMO	Potential Digestive Issues
Organic palm oil is non-GMO as well.	In some rare cases, palm oil might cause digestive issues like harder stools or constipation.

Nutritional Facts Comparison Table

Nutrient	Hipp Goat Stage 1 ?	Jovie Stage 1 ?
Energy	276 kj / 66kcal	276 kj / 66 kcal
Total Fat	3.6g	3.5g
Saturated Fat	1.5g	1.3g
Monounsaturates	1.6g	1.6g
Polyunsaturates	0.5g	0.6g
Linoleic Acid (omega-6)	0.46g	0.48g
a-linolenic Acid (omega-3)	0.06g	0.05g
AA (Arachidonic Acid)	13.2mg	14mg
DHA (Docosahexaenoic Acid)	13.2mg	14mg
Total Carbohydrate	7.6g	7.1g
Sugars	7.8g*	6.8g
Lactose	6.9g	6.8g
Protein	1.3g	1.3g
L-Carnitine	1.3g	1.2g
Sodium	20mg	19mg
Potassium	70mg	78mg
Chloride	58mg	75mg
Calcium	67mg	63mg
Phosphorus	38mg	39mg
Magnesium	5.2mg	5.8mg
Iron	0.5mg	0.6mg
Zinc	0.5mg	0.4mg
Copper	0.053mg	44µg
Manganese	0.005mg	5.6µg
Selenium	3µg	2.3µg
Vitamin A	54µg	50µg
☀️ Vitamin D	4.5µg	1.5µg
Vitamin E	0.66mg	1.4mg
Vitamin K	5.1µg	3.3µg

Probiotics and Prebiotics

Prebiotics and probiotics are gut-friendly ingredients that can support a healthy digestive system in babies.

HiPP Dutch Goat Milk Formula adds a prebiotic fiber derived from lactose.

Jovie’s formula also adds GOS coming from lactose as a prebiotic.

In the world of baby nutrition, prebiotics and probiotics have become somewhat of a buzzword.

While not essential, these gut-friendly ingredients can help support a healthy digestive system, particularly for those little ones needing more assistance in this department.

HiPP Dutch Goat Milk Formula adds a prebiotic fiber (Galacto-oligosaccharides) derived from lactose. This prebiotic fiber nourishes the beneficial gut bacteria, promoting a healthy gut environment, and helping to support your baby’s digestion.

Jovie, while keeping their formula simple and close to the natural composition of goat’s milk, only includes GOS. 

Cost and availability

Cost and availability are often the real-world factors that determine our choices. 

Jovie is often more expensive than HiPP Dutch Goat Milk Formula. However, it’s important to remember that cost isn’t always a reflection of quality, but often comes down to factors like sourcing, manufacturing processes, and the brand’s philosophy.

Both HiPP and Jovie Goat Milk Formulas are readily available through online retailers in the US. (see below the best places to purchase them)

Best Places to Buy Hipp and Jovie

More goat milk formula options beyond Hipp and Jovie worth considering

While HiPP and Jovie are both excellent options for goat milk formula, there are a few other notable brands worth mentioning:

• Kendamil Goat: Made in the UK, Kendamil Goat is a formula that prides itself on using all-natural ingredients, with no GMOs, no artificial preservatives, and no corn syrup. *Read: Kendamil vs Jovie

• Holle Goat: A Swiss brand, Holle Goat is an organic formula that uses goat’s milk as a base and adds vitamins and minerals necessary for your baby’s development. *Read: Holle vs Jovie

• Kabrita: This Dutch brand is a popular choice among parents. Kabrita’s goat milk formula is fortified with vitamins, minerals, and also includes a blend of prebiotic fibers. *Read: Kabrita vs Jovie

Conclusion

Choosing between HiPP and Jovie goat milk formula is like choosing between two high-quality, finely crafted instruments – each with its own unique tune and capable of creating beautiful music.

The best choice depends on what resonates most with your baby’s needs.

We recommend HiPP Dutch Goat Milk Formula if your baby has digestive issues or gets hungry often. Adding prebiotics and maltodextrin can help support digestion and provide sustained energy release.

On the other hand, if you’re willing to spend more on a formula that keeps things simple, Jovie could be your pick. Its formula, free from palm oil and maltodextrin, relies solely on the natural composition of goat’s milk.