NannyCare vs Kendamil Goat: Which Baby Formula Is Better?

Key Differences Between NannyCare and Kendamil Goat

Features	NannyCare	Kendamil Goat
Brand Reputation	Established for 30+ years, New Zealand-based, committed to animal welfare, organic ingredients and sustainable practices	58 years of R&D experience, UK-based, dedicated to nutrition, balance, animal welfare and sustainability
Nutritional Composition	Whole goat milk protein, lactose, vegetable oils, marine fish oil and Mortierella alpina oil powder	Whole goat milk protein, demineralized goat whey powder, lactose, vegetable oils, DHA and ARA from marine algae
Omega-3 source	Fish oil	Marine Algae (Plant-based)
Protein source	Whole goat milk	Whole goat milk and demineralized goat whey powder
Carbohydrate source	Lactose	Lactose
Probiotics and Prebiotics	None added	Galacto-oligosaccharides (GOS)
Cost	Similar to Kendamil Goat	Similar to NannyCare
Availability in the US	More consistent availability	Often sold out
Suitable for Vegetarians	No, due to fish oil	Yes, due to marine algae
Philosophy	Simple, pure goat milk formula	Sustainability and against overfishing

Blwstore is supported by its audience. When you buy through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission.

The world of formula can be overwhelming and, at times, confusing.

Today, we’re going to narrow down the options and take a closer look at two leading brands in the baby formula market: NannyCare and Kendamil.

Specifically, we’ll be comparing NannyCare Stage 1 and Kendamil Goat Stage 1.

While we focus on Stage 1, it’s important to note that our comparison can generally be applied to follow-on formulas as their composition does not vary drastically.

The spotlight is on these two formulas because they have a common ingredient – goat milk – a popular choice for parents looking for an alternative to cow’s milk formula.

So, let’s dive into our NannyCare vs Kendamil comparison.

Our Short Answer

We know navigating the world of baby formulas is difficult, but with NannyCare and Kendamil Goat, you’re in good hands.

Both are superb choices, but they shine in slightly different areas.

• NannyCare provides a more nutritionally complete formula with fish oil-sourced Omega-3.

• Kendamil Goat emphasizes sustainability with plant-based Omega-3 sources.

Choose Kendamil if plant-based nutrition aligns with your philosophy.

Choose NannyCare if you prioritize a simple, pure, and exceptional goat milk formula.

Either way, you’re making a fantastic choice for your little one.

At BLWStore, we may earn a commission from some of the products featured on our website through affiliate partnerships with retailers. We want to be transparent with our readers and let you know that we do not receive any products for special consideration. The commission we earn helps support our website and allows us to continue providing helpful information and product recommendations. Thank you for your support!

Brand Reputation

Understanding a brand’s reputation and philosophy is crucial when choosing a product as intimate as your baby’s food.

After all, the company’s values often translate into the quality and composition of the product.

NannyCare and Kendamil are leading organic infant formula brands, committed to animal welfare, using organic ingredients, and promoting sustainable practices.

Both brands offer formulas for sensitive digestive systems, with Kendamil also including MFGM for cognitive development.

NannyCare Reputation

NannyCare, a New Zealand-based company, has been in the baby formula industry for over 30 years.

Partnering with a cooperative of 71 independent farmers, NannyCare is renowned for its commitment to producing the highest quality goat milk baby formula.

Their formula, NannyCare Stage 1, is tailored to cater to the unique needs of all infants, particularly those with sensitive digestive systems.

NannyCare is more than just a brand; they are innovators. They have been pivotal in driving change in infant formula legislation, making an impact across the EU, UK, and US.

The company’s success is underpinned by their formula: Organic Ingredients + Biodynamic Farming + Happy Animals = Happy Kiddos.

By ensuring the welfare of their animals and using only organic ingredients, they create a product that is as gentle on your baby’s tummy as it is on the environment.

NannyCare is a family-owned business passionate about creating breastfeeding alternatives.

Their unwavering commitment to quality and innovation has made them a market leader in the UK, where they consistently outrank all other baby formulas.

Kendamil Reputation

On the other side of the globe, in the United Kingdom, lies Kendamil.

Despite being a relative newcomer with 58 years of R&D experience, Kendamil has rapidly become one of the most popular brands of organic infant formula.

This is largely due to their meticulous attention to nutrition and balance in their formulas.

Kendamil operates like a tight-knit family, treating their organic milk farmers as one of their own.

They source milk exclusively from farms prioritizing animal welfare and producing as close to nature as possible, avoiding synthetic additives.

All Kendamil formulas, including Kendamil Goat Stage 1, contain no palm oil, soy, corn syrup, or sugar.

Furthermore, they use marine algae instead of fish oil, making their formulas vegetarian-friendly.

Sustainability is central to Kendamil’s philosophy. They strive to limit their CO2 emissions by working only with local suppliers and running their factory on 100% renewable energy.

Kendamil is also committed to preventing over-fishing, using only marine algae to deliver healthy Omega 3 and 6 in its infant formulas.

At Kendamil, innovation is key. They are one of the few formula manufacturers to include MFGM (Milk Fat Globule Membrane) in their product, a component naturally occurring in breast milk, which promotes improved cognitive development in babies.

Nutritional Composition

Both formulas use whole goat milk protein and lactose as the primary carbohydrate, but Kendamil adds demineralized goat whey powder to enhance protein profile and marine algae for vegetarian-friendly DHA and ARA.

NannyCare uses fish oil for omega-3.

Protein Content

Protein is the building block of your baby’s cells. It’s a critical part of their growth and development.

NannyCare Stage 1 formula primarily uses whole goat milk as the protein source, naturally designed for sensitive digestive systems. Goat milk protein is beneficial because it forms a softer curd in the stomach, making it easier to digest.

Kendamil Goat Stage 1 also uses whole goat milk, with the addition of demineralized goat whey powder. This addition enhances the protein profile of the formula, closer resembling the protein structure found in breast milk.

The difference here is that Kendamil adds whey to its mix, making it more closely resemble breastmilk. However, NannyCare does not do this, as it would involve more processing of the formula, and their philosophy is to keep things as straightforward as possible.

There is no right or wrong choice here. We don’t believe this is a key difference that should dictate your decision.

Carbohydrate Content

Carbohydrates are the primary energy source for your baby’s developing brain and body.

NannyCare relies on lactose, derived from milk, as its main carbohydrate source. This is an excellent choice as lactose is the primary carbohydrate found in breast milk.

Kendamil, too, uses lactose as its primary carbohydrate.

It’s worth noting that both formulas avoid cheap, less beneficial carbohydrate sources such as corn syrup or sugar, sticking to the natural choice of lactose.

Fats and Oils

Fats are crucial for your baby’s brain development, absorption of vitamins, and overall growth.

NannyCare opts for a blend of vegetable oils (high oleic sunflower oil, rapeseed oil, sunflower oil) alongside marine fish oil and Mortierella alpina oil powder. These oils provide a good balance of essential fatty acids, including Omega-3 and Omega-6.

Kendamil uses a blend of vegetable oils (sunflower, coconut, rapeseed) as well, but instead of fish oil, it uses docosahexaenoic acid and arachidonic acid sourced from marine algae, making it a more vegetarian-friendly choice.

Regarding fat content, the difference is clear, Kendamil uses algae, avoiding fish oil, because their philosophy is avoid overfishing, and NannyCare does use fish oil.

It’s worth knowing that usually, the omega 3 that comes from fish is more easily absorbed by the human body, while the one coming from plants takes longer and it’s more difficult.

Nutritional Facts Comparison Table

Nutrient	Kendamil Goat Stage 1 ?	NANNYCARE ?
Energy	275/66 kJ/Kcal	280 kj/66 kcal
Total Fat	3.5 g	3.4 g
Saturated Fatty Acids	1.2 g	1.2 g
Unsaturated Fatty Acids	2.3 g	2.6 g
Total Carbs	7.2 g	7.4 g
Sugar	7 g	7.4 g
Protein	1.3 g	1.3 g
Vitamin A	59 mcg-RE	56 µg
Vitamin D3	1.4 mcg	1.4 µg
Vitamin E	2.2 mg-a-TE	1.5 mg
Vitamin K	4.3 mcg	6.7 µg
Vitamin C	12 mg	13 mg
Thiamine	0.06 mg	0.062 mg
Riboflavin	0.15 mg	0.12 mg
Niacin	0.65 mg	0.66 mg
Vitamin B6	0.05 mg	0.036 mg
Folate (DFE)	17 mcg	22 µg DFE
Vitamin B12	0.17 mg	0.18 µg
Pantothenic Acid	0.5 mg	0.35 mg
Biotin	2.8 mcg	2.3 µg
Sodium	22 mg	19 mg
Potassium	84 mg	70 mg
Chloride	52 mg	57 mg
Calcium	44 mg	53 mg
Phosphorous	27 mg	39 mg
Iron	0.7 mg	0.65 mg
Zinc	0.5 mg	0.49 mg
Copper	0.053 mg	0.049 mg
Iodine	13 mcg	13 µg
Selenium	2.5 mcg	2.5 µg
Manganese	7 mcg	9 µg
Taurine	5.8 mg	4.6 mg
Inositol	12 mg	3.9 mg
L-Carnitine	1 mg	0.9 mg

Probiotics and Prebiotics

Prebiotics and probiotics can be beneficial in a baby formula, but they’re not essential, particularly in goat milk formulas.

Why is this?

Because goat milk formulas are already easier to digest than cow’s milk formulas.

NannyCare doesn’t contain added prebiotics or probiotics, focusing instead on maintaining a clean, gentle formula that’s naturally easy to digest due to its goat milk base.

Kendamil Goat Stage 1 includes galacto-oligosaccharides (GOS), a prebiotic, in its formulation. Prebiotics like GOS can help promote a healthy gut microbiome in infants.

Cost and availability

When it comes to cost, NannyCare and Kendamil Goat are quite comparable.

The prices for these premium goat milk formulas reflect their high-quality ingredients and the careful processes that ensure their nutritional completeness.

However, availability can be a different story, especially for parents in the United States.

While both formulas can be purchased through various online retailers, finding Kendamil Goat in the U.S. can often be a challenge.

This formula tends to sell out quickly due to high demand, which can lead to occasional shortages.

NannyCare, on the other hand, generally maintains a more consistent availability.

Best Places to Buy NannyCare and Kendamil Goat

What are the best alternatives to NannyCare and Kendamil Goat?

Other reputable goat milk formulas are available if NannyCare or Kendamil Goat doesn’t meet your needs.

These include Holle Goat, Hipp Dutch Goat, and Kabrita.

• Holle Goat: an organic formula from Germany with high-quality, Demeter-certified ingredients. *Read: Holle vs NannyCare and Holle Goat vs Kendamil Goat

• Hipp Dutch Goat: an organic formula known for its balanced formulation. *Read: Hipp vs NannyCare

• Kabrita: a Dutch brand offering a goat milk toddler formula that’s gentle and easy to digest. *Read: Kabrita vs NannyCare

Conclusion

NannyCare and Kendamil Goat are among the best goat milk formulas available, if not the best, in the world. Whichever you choose, you’re making a fantastic choice for your little one.

Having said that, NannyCare offers a slightly more nutritionally complete formula due to the inclusion of fish oil as their Omega-3 source.

On the other hand, Kendamil stands out with its commitment to sustainability and its philosophy against overfishing, which leads it to source Omega-3 from plant-based sources.

If you’re looking for a plant-based formula, Kendamil will be your top choice.

If you’re after a simple, pure, and fantastic goat milk formula, NannyCare stands as the winner.