NannyCare vs Holle: Which Goat Milk Formula Is Better?

Key Differences Between NannyCare and Holle

	Holle	NannyCare
Origin	Switzerland	New Zealand
Main Carbohydrate	Organic lactose, organic maltodextrin	Lactose from goat’s milk
Protein Source	Organic full-cream goat’s milk	Whole goat milk
Fats and Oils	Blend of organic vegetable oils, full cream goat’s milk	Blend of vegetable oils, full cream goat milk
Probiotics and Prebiotics	Not included	Not included
Cost	Similarly priced	Similarly priced
Availability	Available in online European Formula retailers in the US	Available in online European Formula retailers in the US
Addition of Maltodextrin	Yes	No
Purity	High-quality, but includes maltodextrin	High-quality, purest goat milk formula
Ideal for	Babies who are usually very hungry or wake up hungry at night	Babies for whom you want the purest goat milk formula

Blwstore is supported by its audience. When you buy through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission.

As a parent, you want the best for your child, especially regarding nutrition.

Navigating the world of baby formulas can be daunting, with various brands and types to choose from.

Here, we comprehensively compare two renowned goat milk formula brands: NannyCare and Holle.

We will compare their stage 1 versions. However, our insights can also be applied to their follow-on formulas as there are a few differences.

So, let’s dive into the world of NannyCare vs. Holle and find out which goat milk formula is superior for your baby’s needs.

Our Short Answer

Holle Goat and NannyCare are exceptional goat milk-based formulas, but they cater to different needs.

• If your baby tends to be hungrier and needs a formula to keep them satisfied longer, Holle Goat, with its inclusion of maltodextrin, is a fantastic choice.

• But if purity and simplicity are what you’re after, NannyCare should be your top pick.

We’ve had great experiences with Holle Goat, but we recognize that NannyCare offers an unmatched purity level in its formulas.

At BLWStore, we may earn a commission from some of the products featured on our website through affiliate partnerships with retailers. We want to be transparent with our readers and let you know that we do not receive any products for special consideration. The commission we earn helps support our website and allows us to continue providing helpful information and product recommendations. Thank you for your support!

Brand Reputation

In the baby nutrition industry, brand reputation is vital.

It serves as a testament to a company’s commitment to quality, safety, and customer satisfaction.

A good brand reputation often indicates high-quality products that parents can trust. 

NannyCare uses high-quality goat milk from 71 independent farmers and is ranked number one across the UK.

Holle offers Demeter-certified formulas, including organic goat milk, with a focus on sustainability and CO2 neutrality.

Both brands adhere to strict organic and non-GMO standards and avoid using synthetic ingredients, sugars, and palm oil.

NannyCare Reputation

NannyCare is a New Zealand-based company that has been in the business of producing high-quality goat milk baby formulas for over 30 years.

This family-owned business is a pioneer in goat milk science and has been instrumental in influencing infant formula legislation.

Their commitment to quality and safety has led to NannyCare being ranked as the number one baby formula across the UK.

NannyCare’s formula is produced in partnership with a cooperative of 71 independent farmers. Their mission is simple: Organic Ingredients + Biodynamic Farming + Happy Animals = Happy Kiddos.

They source their goat milk from farms specializing in producing milk best suited for babies.

The resulting formula is gentle and uses only essential ingredients, avoiding many processing steps and heat cycles used in standard whey-based recipes.

NannyCare Goat Milk Formula is Non-GMO and contains no soy, palm oil, sugars, or synthetic ingredients. 

As an indicator of its commitment to quality, NannyCare’s goat milk formula meets the stringent European Union organic standards, and the company is continually dedicated to making changes that positively impact families across the EU, UK, and US.

Holle Reputation

On the other side of the world, in Switzerland, Holle has been a household name for over 85 years.

Their commitment to farming sustainability and product quality has made them one of the first in Europe to achieve organic Demeter certification for their products.

At its core, Holle is known for its Demeter-certified baby formulas that offer balanced nutrition with fewer ingredients to promote easy digestion.

Beyond cow milk formulas, Holle has specialized in a variety of organic goat milk formulas, offering a helpful alternative for babies with digestive sensitivity to milk proteins.

Holle’s commitment to sustainability extends beyond its farming practices. The company recently audited its global manufacturing infrastructure to reduce CO2 emissions, making its baby formulas CO2 neutral.

Holle Goat Stage 1 Organic Infant Milk Formula, like all Holle formulas, is organic, sugar-free, corn syrup free, and made to strict European Union organic standards, which are more stringent than comparable standards in the United States.

The formula is also gluten- and GMO-free and free from synthetic additives, artificial nutrients, preservatives, and artificial flavorings.

Nutritional Composition

Nannycare uses lactose from goat’s milk while Holle includes organic maltodextrin and organic lactose, providing a slightly higher carbohydrate content.

Both formulas avoid palm oil and combine vegetable oils, providing essential fatty acids for babies.

Protein Content

Nannycare Stage 1 Goat Milk Formula sources its protein directly from whole goat milk, a unique choice that ensures a softer curd, closely mimicking breast milk and facilitating easier digestion.

Holle Goat Stage 1 Organic also derives its protein content from organic full-cream goat’s milk, ensuring a protein composition that closely resembles the natural breast milk.

In terms of protein content, Nannycare provides 1.3g per 100ml, while Holle offers slightly more at 1.4g per 100ml. 

Both formulas are almost equal in terms of protein content and sources.

Carbohydrate Content

Carbohydrates are essential for providing energy to your little one’s rapidly growing body.

Nannycare Goat Stage 1 Formula uses lactose from goat’s milk as its primary carbohydrate source, offering 7.4g per 100ml.

In contrast, Holle Goat Stage 1 Organic also uses organic lactose but incorporates organic maltodextrin, resulting in a slightly higher carbohydrate content of 7.5g per 100ml.

Pros and Cons of Organic Maltodextrin In Infant Formulas

Features	Pros ✅	Cons ❌
Easily Digestible	Releases energy at a slower rate, making babies feel fuller.	Some babies may experience mild allergic reactions to maltodextrin, like to any other ingredient.
Low Sweetness	Can help prevent a preference for overly sweet tastes from developing early in life.	Maltodextrin can sometimes spike blood sugar levels, but only happens by overconsuming it.
Thickening Property	Makes the mixing process easier and also more filling.	Maltodextrin is less nutritious as compared to other complex carbohydrates.
Quick source of energy	Can be beneficial for growing babies and make them more physically active.
Organic Standards and non-GMO	Doesn’t contain any genetically modified organisms.

Fats and Oils

When comparing the fat content, Nannycare delivers 3.4g per 100ml from a blend of vegetable oils and full cream goat milk.

Holle, on the other hand, offers a higher fat content of 3.6g per 100ml, derived from organic vegetable oils and full cream goat’s milk.

Both formulas avoid palm oil and instead use a combination of high oleic sunflower oil, rapeseed oil, and sunflower oil, providing essential fatty acids for your baby’s brain development and overall growth.

Nutritional Facts Comparison Table

Nutrient	NannyCare	Holle Goat
Energy	66 kcal	68 kcal
Total Fat	3.4 g	3.6 g
Saturates	1.2 g	1.3 g
Monounsaturates	1.6 g	1.7 g
Polyunsaturates	0.53 g	0.6 g
Linoleic Acid (Omega 6)	400 mg	510 mg
Linolenic Acid (Omega 3)	53 mg	54 mg
DHA	15 mg	13.9 mg
Total Carbs	7.4 g	7.5 g
Sugars	7.4 g	4.0 g
Inositol	3.9 mg	3.6 mg
Sodium	19 mg	19 mg
Potassium	70 mg	72.6 mg
Protein	1.3 g	1.4 g
L-Carnitine	0.9 mg	1.0 mg
Calcium	53 mg	60.7 mg
Iron	0.65 mg	0.67 mg
Phosphorus	39 mg	41.8 mg
Chloride	57 mg	75.9 mg
Zinc	0.49 mg	0.46 mg
Copper	0.049 mg	0.048 mg
Iodine	13 mcg	13.6 mcg
Selenium	2.5 mcg	2.4 mcg
Vitamin C	13 mg	9.2 mg
Vitamin A	56 mcg	54.1 mcg RE
☀️ Vitamin D3	1.4 mcg	1.5 mcg
Vitamin E	1.5 mg	1.3 mg
Vitamin B1	0.062 mg	0.052 mg
Vitamin B2	0.12 mg	0.077 mg
Vitamin B6	0.036 mg	0.038 mg

Probiotics and Prebiotics

Nannycare and Holle Goat Stage 1 formulas do not include prebiotics and probiotics, as goat milk is naturally easier to digest than cow milk, with lower amounts of complex proteins.

We often hear about the benefits of prebiotics and probiotics, especially in promoting gut health.

However, it’s important to note that neither Nannycare nor Holle Goat Stage 1 formulas include these.

But why is that?  Aren’t they beneficial for digestion?

Absolutely, they can be! However, goat’s milk is already easier to digest than cow’s milk due to its naturally softer curds and lower amounts of certain complex proteins.

While prebiotics and probiotics may benefit some babies, they’re often less necessary in goat milk-based formulas.

Cost and availability

Nannycare and Holle Goat Stage 1 formulas are similarly priced, ensuring you don’t need to compromise quality for affordability.

These formulas are readily available via several online European Formula retailers in the United States, offering you the convenience of home delivery. *Read: Where to Buy Goat Milk Formula

Rest assured, these platforms ensure the safe and secure purchase of these baby formulas so you can feel confident in your choice.

Best Places to Buy NannyCare and Holle

What are the best alternatives to NannyCare and Holle Goat?

While Holle Goat and Nannycare are top-notch goat milk formulas, other worthy alternatives also deserve consideration. Here are some powerful options:

• Hipp Dutch Goat: This formula offers a blend of quality goat’s milk and essential nutrients, perfect for babies with sensitive stomachs. *Read: Hipp vs NannyCare

• Kendamil Goat: Kendamil provides a high-quality goat milk formula with a reputation for its organic ingredients and nutritional balance. *Read: Kendamil vs NannyCare

• Kabrita: A non-GMO formula, Kabrita is well-regarded for its digestibility and nutrient-rich content. *Read: Kabrita vs NannyCare

Conclusion

The main distinction between Holle Goat and Nannycare lies in the addition of maltodextrin in Holle’s formula.

If your baby often wakes up hungry at night or seems constantly hungry, Holle may be the better option, as maltodextrin is known to keep babies satisfied for extended periods.

However, if you’re looking for the purest goat milk formula available, NannyCare is probably your go-to formula.

We’ve used Holle Goat in the past and loved it, but NannyCare goes one step further regarding purity and simplicity.