Holle vs Kabrita: Which Goat Milk Formula Is Better?

Key differences between Holle Goat and Kabrita

Features/Aspect	Holle Goat Milk Formula	Kabrita Goat Milk Formula
Primary Ingredient	Organic whole goat’s milk	Skimmed goat milk and whey proteins
Artificial Sweeteners or Preservatives	No, free from artificial additives	No, free from harmful chemicals
Key Nutrients	Rich in essential fatty acids, DHA (Omega-3), ARA (Omega-6)	Enriched with 22 vitamins and minerals, Beta-palmitate, DHA (from fish oil)
Digestive Health	Simple ingredient list for easy digestion	Contains prebiotics (GOS) for digestive health
GMO, Gluten, Soy, Palm Oil	Free from GMOs, gluten, soy, palm oil	Free from pesticides, steroids, chemicals
Fat Sources	Vegetable oils (sunflower, rapeseed), oils from microalgae	Blend of vegetable oils (coconut, rapeseed, sunflower), high sn-2 Palmitic Acid Oil
Certifications	Demeter International, European Union organic, Bioland, KRAV	Complies with strict European certification standards
Special Features	Aimed at being close to breastmilk, supports natural digestion	Balanced nutritional profile, Non-GMO, Beta-palmitate for mineral absorption

Are you a parent looking for a goat milk formula for your little one?

In this article, we will compare two popular goat milk formula brands, Holle and Kabrita, to help you make an informed decision.

We will analyze their ingredients and nutritional composition to help you choose the best one for your little one.

Let’s get after it!

Are you more of a listener? Here’s our Youtube video discussing Holle and Kabrita:

Our short answer

After analyzing both formulas one thing is clear: whichever one you choose, we assure you that you will be buying one of the best formulas for your baby.

Formulas made with goat’s milk are usually better for most babies to those made with cow’s milk, and even more so if they are of the quality that both Holle and Kabrita have.

That said, if we had to choose one for our baby, we would opt for Holle, for the simple reason that it uses whole milk.

If we see that after a few weeks he suffers from digestive problems, we would try Kabrita, since on paper, it is easier to digest.

Overview of the Two Formulas

Holle Goat Milk Formula offers nutrition from organic whole goat’s milk, free from artificial sweeteners, preservatives, GMOs, gluten, soy, and palm oil. It’s rich in essential fatty acids and has a simple ingredient list for easy digestion.

Kabrita Goat Milk Formula is designed for the same age range, with a balanced nutritional profile, Beta-palmitate for better mineral absorption, prebiotics for digestive health, and is free from harmful chemicals, featuring coconut and fish oils for cognitive development.

Holle Goat

Holle Goat Milk Formula is recognized for its simplicity and organic ingredients. Suitable from birth, Holle is an excellent source of nutrition, perfect as a complete food source or a complement to breastfeeding. This formula is crafted from EU-certified organic whole goat’s milk and ensures high quality and safety standards.

The key attributes of Holle Goat include:

• Organic whole goat milk: The primary ingredient ensures babies receive nutrition from a natural and easily digestible source.
• No artificial sweeteners or preservatives: Its clean ingredient list is free from potentially harmful additives, GMOs, gluten, soy, and palm oil.
• Rich in essential fatty acids: It contains both ARA (Omega-6) and plant-based DHA (Omega-3), vital for baby’s brain development.
• Short and simple ingredient list: Aimed at being close to breastmilk’s composition, it supports natural digestion and alleviates common digestive troubles such as gas or colic.

Holle also has certifications from various organizations, including Demeter International, European Union Organic, Bioland, and KRAV, which attest to their commitment to sustainable and eco-friendly farming practices.

Kabrita

Kabrita Goat Milk Formula distinguishes itself with its specialized blend tailored for babies from birth. The Dutch-made formula uses 100% natural premium goat milk and additional important nutrients supporting healthy growth.

Key features include:

• Balanced nutritional profile: Enriched with 22 vitamins and minerals that mimic those found in human breast milk.
• Contains Beta-palmitate: A naturally occurring fatty acid similar to that in mother’s milk, which plays a role in improving mineral absorption and metabolism.
• Prebiotics for digestive health: Oligosaccharides act as prebiotics, making it easier on babies’ tummies and helping with nutrient absorption.

Kabrita also boasts of being free from pesticides, steroids, or chemicals thanks to strict European certification standards. Its blend includes vegetable oils such as coconut oil and crucial fatty acids like DHA (from fish oil) that contribute to cognitive development.

While Kabrita may not have the same level of history and certification as Holle, it has earned a positive reputation among many parents looking for a goat milk formula option.

Nutritional Composition

Holle Goat uses whole goat milk proteins and essential amino acids, ideal for sensitive infants, while Kabrita employs skimmed goat milk and whey proteins with beneficial Beta-palmitate.

Both use lactose as the primary carbohydrate, with Kabrita adding prebiotic GOS.

Holle Goat relies on less vegetable oils for fats, whereas Kabrita combines various oils, including beneficial coconut oil and high sn-2 Palmitic Acid Oil.

Protein Content

Holle Goat:
The primary source of protein in Holle Goat formula comes from whole goat milk powder and full-cream goat milk powder. This creates a natural and easily digestible source of protein suitable for infants, particularly those sensitive to cow’s milk proteins. Including essential amino acids like L-tyrosine, L-tryptophan, and L-cystine supports healthy growth and development.

Kabrita:
Kabrita utilizes skimmed goat milk and goat whey protein concentrate powder as its main protein sources. These ingredients provide a balanced mix of casein and whey proteins similar to what is found in breast milk. Beta-palmitate is beneficial as it mimics the structure of human milk fat, promoting better calcium absorption and energy utilization.

Holle wins the protein battle thanks to using whole milk instead of skimmed like Kabrita. This means Holle is less reliant on vegetable oils because milk fat is more bioavailable and of higher quality than plant-based fats.

Carbohydrate Content

Holle Goat:
In Holle’s formula, lactose is used as the primary carbohydrate source, mimicking the lactose content in breast milk. This choice supports a gentle digestion process, making it ideal for babies with sensitive stomachs or issues such as gas, bloating, or colic. There is no inclusion of corn syrup, starch, or maltodextrin, common in many other formulas but can sometimes cause digestive discomfort.

Kabrita:
Similarly to Holle Goat, Kabrita also uses lactose derived from milk as its main carbohydrate content. However, it goes further by including Galacto-oligosaccharides (GOS), prebiotic fibers found naturally occurring in breast milk that promote healthy gut bacteria aiding digestion.

Both formulas are the same on paper, using lactose exclusively, without any other artificial sugar.

Fat and Oils Content

Holle Goat:
The fats in Holle Goat come primarily from vegetable oils such as sunflower and rapeseed. Additionally included are oils from microalgae Schizochytrium sp., which provide DHA (a form of Omega-3), and Mortierella Alpina offering ARA (a type of Omega-6). These fatty acids are crucial for brain development while ensuring infants receive energy through easily metabolized sources.

Kabrita:
In contrast to Holle Goat’s approach towards fat composition using plant-based oils solely, Kabrita’s formulation includes a blend of vegetable oils (coconut oil, rapeseed oil, sunflower oil) alongside high sn-2 Palmitic Acid Oil derived from Palm Oil, creating a closer mimicry to breast milk fat structure—supporting infant metabolism effectively. Furthermore it adds Docosahexaenoic Acid Rich Oil (DHA) sourced from fish ensuring an intake of vital Omega-3 fatty acids necessary for neurological development.

Holle would win because it has whole milk fats, as we said before. However, if we do not consider this, Kabrita would be superior thanks to adding coconut oil (the best plant-based oil) and Palmitic Acid without using palm oil directly.

Probiotics and Prebiotics Comparison

A baby’s digestive system is delicate and still developing, making it crucial to include probiotics and prebiotics in their diet. These supplements support a healthy gut by promoting the growth of beneficial bacteria, aiding digestion, and improving nutrient absorption.

• Holle Goat mainly focuses on simple, easily digestible ingredients that naturally support the digestive process. While not specifically mentioning the addition of probiotics or prebiotics in its ingredients list, Holle Goat ensures a gentle formula suited for sensitive stomachs through its choice of natural components.
• Kabrita, on the other hand, explicitly includes Galacto-oligosaccharides (GOS) as a form of prebiotic. GOS are derived from lactose and help to foster a healthy balance of gut bacteria. This addition supports easier digestion for infants, particularly those transitioning from breast milk or experiencing sensitivity to other formulas.

Best Places to Buy Holle and Kabrita

What are The Best alternatives to Holle and Kabrita?

Holle and Kabrita are two of the top brands in the formula market right now. However, we always recommend to read about all the great alternatives before you make a purchasing decision.

Here are our favorites:

• Kendamil Goat: This UK-made formula emphasizes whole goat milk alongside prebiotics (GOS), Omega-3 DHA, Omega-6 ARA from marine sources ensuring a well-rounded nutritional profile focusing on local sourcing and absence of palm oil. *Read: Kendamil Goat vs Holle Goat | Kendamil vs Kabrita

• Nannycare: Originated in New Zealand; Nannycare offers goat milk-based nutrition focused on easy digestibility with a natural blend free from added artificial nutrients enhancing its appeal for simplicity. *Read: Nannycare vs Kabrita | Nannycare vs Holle Goat

• Jovie: Jovie takes pride in its organic goat milk formula rich in AlphaS1-casein protein, making it closer to human breast milk while including both GOS for prebiotic benefits and DHA and ARA from algae sources, avoiding fish oil. *Read: Jovie vs Kabrita | Jovie vs Holle

• Hipp Goat: Known for its organic cow’s milk formulae, Hipp also offers an organic goat milk option designed with quality proteins; it also includes natural prebiotics similar to those found in breastmilk, supporting infant gut health. *Read: Hipp Goat vs Kabrita

Last Words

We hope this Holle Goat and Kabrita comparison has helped you choose the best formula for your baby.

If you still have questions, feel free to comment below or ask us at [email protected].

Happy feeding!