Hipp vs Bobbie: What’s the Best Formula for Your Baby?

Key differences between Hipp and Bobbie

Aspect	Hipp	Bobbie
Brand reputation	Well-known and reputable European brand with over 60 years of experience	New American formula brand with European standards
Nutritional composition	Organic milk protein and whey protein, organic lactose, and organic vegetable oils, including palm oil	Organic milk protein and whey protein, organic lactose, and vegetable oils such as coconut oil and sunflower oil
Probiotics and prebiotics	Contains prebiotics and probiotics, promoting gut health	Does not contain prebiotics or probiotics
Cost and availability	Only available online, price range from about $1.50 to $3.00 per ounce	Only available for purchase directly from the company’s website or through a subscription, $26 per 400g can or around $2.00 per ounce
Key pros	Top-quality organic formulas with 100+ years of history and tradition; wide range of products with alternatives for everyone; suitable even for kids with various allergies and intolerances	Only American formula that fully complies with the official EU regulations; 100% organic ingredients; FDA approved and widely available in the US; mimics breast milk as closely as possible
Key cons	Not FDA-approved yet; cannot be bought in standard American shops – only online.	No prebiotics or probiotics

In this article, we’ll compare two popular formulas: Hipp vs Bobbie.

We will analyze the ingredients and nutritional compositions of Hipp Dutch 1 and Bobbie to help you decide which formula is the best for your baby.

Hipp has many specialty formulas like Hipp Comfort, Anti-Reflux, and Hypoallergenic. We will not compare those to Bobbie because they are designed for babies with special needs.

Let’s get after it!

If you are more of a listener, check out our Youtube video:

Our Short Answer

Based on our experience, both Hipp and Bobbie are excellent organic formulas, but they have some differences that may make one more suitable for your baby’s needs than the other.

If your baby has sensitive stomach or digestive issues, we recommend Hipp, which is known for being gentle on delicate tummies.

However, if you’re looking for a formula that is made with a simple and pure ingredients list, Bobbie may be the better choice for you.

It’s worth noting that Bobbie has experienced stock problems in the past, which could be a consideration when making your decision.

Brand Reputation

Hipp Reputation

Hipp is a well-known and reputable baby formula brand from Europe that has been in business for over 60 years.

They are a healthy option for infants with sensitive stomachs because they don’t include hazardous chemicals or artificial preservatives.

Hipp also provides a wide choice of formula types and stages, including unique formulations for newborns with sensitivities and allergies.

Hipp formulas are well-liked in Europe, but they are only available online and are not yet FDA-approved in the US. Nevertheless, many parents who have tried them praise Hipp for their effectiveness and high quality.

Bobbie Reputation

Bobbie is a new formula brand in the American market founded by two moms searching for a better organic formula for their children.

Bobbie’s formula is modeled after the European formula, known for its strict regulations on organic ingredients, the prohibition of GMOs, and the use of specific amounts of DHA.

Bobbie’s is FDA-approved and is the only American formula that fully complies with the official EU regulations.

Bobbie’s formula is free from palm oil and added sugar. It contains essential vitamins and minerals, making it an excellent option for parents looking for a high-quality organic formula for their infants.

Nutritional Composition

When choosing a formula for your baby, it’s essential to consider the nutritional composition.

Here, we will compare the protein, carbohydrate, and fat content of Hipp and Bobbie formulas.

The short

Nutrient	Hipp Formula	Bobbie Formula
Protein	Organic milk protein and whey protein	Organic milk protein and whey protein
Carbohydrates	Organic lactose as the primary carbohydrate	Organic lactose as the primary carbohydrate
Fats and Oils	Contains organic vegetable oils, such as palm oil, rapeseed oil, and sunflower oil, as well as organic cream	Contains organic vegetable oils, such sunflower, and coconut

Nutritional Information Comparison: Hipp vs Bobbie

	Hipp Stage 1	Bobbie
Protein	1.28g	2g
Fat	3.6g	5.3g
Carbohydrate	7g	11g
Linoleic Acid	0.4g	1g
Vitamin C	8.9mg	9mg
Vitamin A	54μg RAE	300 IU
☀️ Vitamin D	1.5μg (60 IU)	70 IU
Vitamin E	0.7mg α-TE	2 IU
⚡️ Vitamin K	5.1μg	8.3mcg
Calcium	51mg	63mg
Iron	0.5mg	1.2mg

Hipp Composition

Hipp formulas are made from organic ingredients designed to mimic breast milk’s nutrient composition as closely as possible.

Hipp formulas contain a balanced amount of protein, carbohydrates, and fats suitable for babies of all ages.

Proteins

Hipp gives your infant a nearly equal substitute for breast milk by using whey protein, which has a protein ratio similar to breast milk.

In their specially developed hypoallergenic and anti-reflux formulas, 100% of the whey protein is hydrolyzed to make it easier for infants with sensitive tummies to digest.

Carbohydrates

Hipp formulas contain lactose, the primary carbohydrate in breast milk.

Lactose is an important energy source for babies and helps absorb calcium and other minerals.

Fats and oils

Hipp formulas contain a blend of organic vegetable oils, such as rapeseed, sunflower, and organically grown palm oil, to provide a good balance of essential fatty acids.

The fat content of Hipp formulas is also similar to that of breast milk.

Bobbie Composition

Bobbie formulas are also designed to mimic the nutrient composition of breast milk as closely as possible.

Bobbie formulas contain a balance of protein, carbohydrates, and fats suitable for babies of all ages.

Proteins

Bobbie formulas contain protein from cow’s milk and whey protein, which is easy for babies to digest.

The protein content of Bobbie formulas is carefully balanced to meet the needs of growing infants, and the amino acid profile is similar to that of breast milk.

Carbohydrates

Bobbie formulas contain lactose, the primary carbohydrate in breast milk.

Lactose is an essential energy source for babies and helps absorb calcium and other minerals.

Fats and oils

Bobbie formulas use a blend of vegetable oils, such as coconut and sunflower, to balance essential fatty acids well.

The fat content of Bobbie formulas is also similar to that of breast milk.

Probiotics and Prebiotics

Hipp and Bobbie differ in their approach to probiotics and prebiotics.

Hipp formula is known for containing prebiotics, which are dietary fibers that promote the growth of beneficial gut bacteria, specifically galactooligosaccharides (GOS) and fructooligosaccharides (FOS).

These prebiotics have been shown to reduce the incidence of gastrointestinal infections, diarrhea, and colic in infants.

Additionally, Hipp formula contains probiotics such as Lactobacillus fermentum and bifidobacterium infantis, which can further enhance gut health by adding beneficial bacteria to the digestive system.

On the other hand, Bobbie formula does not contain any prebiotics or probiotics.

Therefore, regarding probiotics and prebiotics, Hipp formula may be better for parents looking for a formula that promotes gut health.

On the other hand, Bobbie formula may be more suitable for parents who do not want to include prebiotics or probiotics in their baby’s diet or prefer to add them separately.

Best Places to Buy Hipp and Bobbie

Hipp

Bobbie (Their official website)

What are the Best Alternatives to Hipp and Bobbie?

Hipp and Bobbie are two of the best formulas in the world. However, there are other alternatives you should explore before making a purchasing decision.

Here are our favorites:

Kendamil sets itself apart with its British heritage, emphasizing a natural approach. It’s the only formula that champions whole milk, cutting down on vegetable oils and saying no to palm oil. Its formula is a hit for those seeking a vegetarian option. It is rich in Omega 3 from algae and includes the beneficial Milk Fat Globule Membrane (MFGM) for a closer-to-nature feeding experience. *Read: Kendamil vs Hipp | Kendamil vs Bobbie

Holle is the go-to for organic purity, sourcing milk from biodynamic farms in southern Germany. Holle is committed to sustainability and incorporates Demeter-certified milk and environmentally friendly palm oil. Its formula, enriched with DHA from algae, is designed to complement breastfeeding, offering a wholesome alternative for parents. *Read: Holle vs Hipp | Holle vs Bobbie

Nannycare, though not detailed here, typically follows suit with a focus on quality and nutrition. Brands like Nannycare are known for their emphasis on natural ingredients and adherence to safety standards, ensuring your baby receives the best care right from the start. *Read: Nannycare vs Holle

Last Words

We hope this comparison between Hipp and Bobbie has helped you make a proper decision for your little one.

If you have further questions, feel free to leave a comment or contact us at [email protected] and we’ll be happy to help you.

Happy feeding!